Showing posts sorted by relevance for query 21st. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query 21st. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, May 21, 2023

21st Century Skills – the last refuge of human exceptionalism!

The rhetoric around AI and automation for the last two decades was “
don’t worry - AI & automation will only tackle the routine jobs”. The whole narrative was owned by the professional classes and centred around workers losing their jobs, not the graduate class working at home on Zoom. We were quick to forget how completely wrong we were. The 21st century skills rhetoric has become the last refuge of human exceptionalism, the topic I covered in my last blog.

 

Stages of 21st C grief

Predictably, the professional class, especially learning professionals, go through their five stages of grief, when faced with new technology: 

 

Denial – bewildered they want to ridicule it through clickbait examples of how bad it is, then say block it and ban it

Anger – sabre rattling stage where mostly 3rd rate academics write open letters, warn people of the dangers which only ‘they’ perceive

Bargaining - form ethics committees, write frameworks and generally do their report writing thing

Depression – oh dear we do have to actually learn to work with this stuff

Acceptance – alright, I give in

 

In denial

We’re still in the ‘denial stage. Taking the usual refuge in the rhetoric of vague 21st C skills. But the mistake is to:


1) think these skills are new
2) think we have a clear definition

2) think of them as skills in themselves, as they mostly need domain knowledge 

2) assume that educators have these skills, even if they did exist in a clean form

3) assume that they know how to teach these skills

4) assume that they are wholly unique to we humans

 

The whole thing goes back to the late 1990s, when we were faced with a new millennium. but a key document was  "Partnership for 21st Century Skills," published in 2002 by a coalition of education organizations in the US. This report put great emphasis  on the ‘c’ words and saw them as essential to prepare students for the challenges and opportunities of the 21st century. 

 

Then the bandwagon, report-writing brigade, organizations such as the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and the World Economic Forum (WEF) began pumping out the rhetoric highlighting the significance of 21st-century skills in their discussions on education and workforce readiness.

 

Nothing new

Mirjam Neelen & Paul A. Kirschner rightfully pointed out, in their excellent blog ‘21st Century Skills don't exist. So why do we need them? (2016) that there is nothing new about these skills, nothing 21st century about them. This was all laid out in the first major counter attack in 2010 from Rotherham & Willingham’s “21st-Century skills. Not new, but a worthy challenge.” I have been making the same point for the last 20 years.

 

Problem of definition

As they pointed out, the first problem, as expected, is definition. They often appear as a list of five or so things on PowerPoint, most starting with the letter ‘C’; communications, collaboration, critical thinking, creativity… then it tails off into the vagueness of problem solving and innovation. There are literally dozens of lists and variations.

 

Skills are notoriously difficult to pin down as they are not, as Bloom suggested represented in some simplistic pyramid They are complex sets of personality traits, motivations, learned knowledge and behaviour – it’s the sum of lots of integrated parts that results in an ability, competence or performance. The fact that it is complicated, mostly involving domain knowledge, makes these very vague 21st C skills difficult to extract as a separate ‘skill’. It is doubtful whether they can be abstracted from domain knowledge at all. Knowledge is marbled like fat into the meat of skills.

 

This 21st C agenda can also be quite dangerous. It can harm learners, especially the disadvantaged by giving them the illusion of progress. Knowledge and skills are not separable like oil and water, they are deeply entwined, so most critical thinking and problem solving requires a depth of knowledge. The 21st C skills agenda led to a hideous focus on ‘Leadership’ in L&D. We assumed that skills were intellectual in some way, so introduced this elitist, hierarchical training, at the expense of real skills and competences for all. We became exclusive not inclusive. That did not go well, as productivity did not increase and although we have lots of rhetoric and training on Leadership, we seem to have precious little of it.

 

AI hits the fan

We’re 23% into the 21st C and they have the last bastion of human exceptionalism (see last blog). The 21st C skills mantra, that has now turned into an empty trope in the Age of AI, especially among educators and learning professionals who needed a serious sounding phrase to rattle around in conferences and reports. It is usually to be found in some overlong, text-heavy Powerpoint presentation at a conference, accompanied by a cocktail of 'C' words  - communication,, collaboration, creativity, critical thinking. Can the real world really be that alliterative?

 

Communication

Young people communicate every few minutes – it’s an obsession. They text, message, chat, post, comment, whatsapp, use Instagram, Facebook, Tik Tok and tools you're you may never to have heard of in various media, including images and video. Note the absence of email and Twitter, the only place you’re likely to hear of 21st C skills. This generation grew up in the 21st C. Never have so many communicated so often with so many. We readily forget that within a few generations, we have moved from letters to the telegraph, then telephone and now free communications, in a bewildering array of types and formats to almost anyone on the planet – for free. Technology not only increases the possibilities in communications, also the skills, through use.

 

In fact, one of the features of Generative AI, such as ChatGPT, is in showing us how poor our communications’ skills can be. It invariably improves almost anything we want to write and send.

 

Collaboration

There’s an abundance of collaboration online, where we share, tag, upload and download experiences, comments, photographs, video, media and now generative AI tools. We collaborate closely in teams, often international, when playing computer games and in the workplace. Never have we shared so much, so often, in so many different ways.

 

Then along comes someone who wants to teach this collaboration as a 21st C skill, usually in a classroom, where much of this technology is banned, ignoring how collaboration works in the real world. I’m hugely amused at this conceit, that we adults, especially in education, think we always have these skills. There is no area of human endeavour that is less collaborative than education. Teaching and lecturing are largely lone-wolf activities in classrooms. Schools, colleges and Universities share little. Educational professionals are deeply suspicious of anything produced outside of their classroom or their institution. The culture of NIH (Not Invented Here) is endemic. Many educators far from being consistently collaborative, are doggedly fixated with delivery by the individual.

 

With AI, especially generteive AI, collaboration at a global, human level, a huge, sophisticated and elegant collective model, trained on the sum of human knowledge. Generative AI is collaboration writ large, the whole of our collaborative cultural capital is being put to good use and available to the individual.

 

Critical thinking 

Critical thinking is the Little Bighorn of human exceptionalism, General Custer’s last stand. Academics, in particular, are fond of these two words, as they see themselves as having these skills in abundance. To be fair soft skills and empathy is not their strong point, so they need something to fall back on. 

 

One species of critical thinking is often well taught in good schools and universities, but only at the level of research, text and essays. As a practical skill it has all but disappeared in theory dominated courses.  It needs high quality teaching and the whole curriculum and system of assessment needs to adjust to this need. As Arun has shown, there is evidence that in our Universities, this is not happening. Arun (2011), in a study that tracked a nationally representative sample of more than 2,000 students, who entered 24 four-year colleges, showed that Universities were failing badly on the three skills they studied; critical thinking, complex reasoning and communications. This research, along with similar evidence, is laid out in their book Academically Adrift. Even research is now under threat as papers appear, where the hypothesis, data work, even the writing is being done by AI.

 

The idea that critical thinking is a uniquely human activity is being challenged by tools that do it better, whether in mathematics or other fields. It is now clear that the inference capabilities of AI will outclass humans and that we are no longer the sole producers of critical analysis. We saw how AI became highly competent at all human games. AI has already defined the 3D structure of the 200 million know proteins, a task that, according to Hassabis, the CEO of Deepmind, would have taken us a billion years using traditional human methods. It’s data analysis abilities have become superb and the growth of the inference side of AI is accelerating fast. We can expect current models top become good at this very quickly.

 

Creativity

The modern understanding of the artist as a unique individual with a distinct creative vision began to emerge during the Renaissance in Europe, strengthened when the Romantic conception of the artist emerged in the late 18th and early 19th centuries as a reaction to rationalism and industrialization. Romanticism placed a strong emphasis on individualism, emotion, imagination, and the awe-inspiring power of nature. Within this context, the creative artist was seen as a visionary figure, capable of tapping into the depths of human experience and expressing profound emotions and ideas. Technology, of course, has always been part of artistic production and expression, from the tools of painting to photography, synthesizers and other generative tools. The idea that art is some sort of divine spark has long gone. Suddenly, generative AI was winning photography competitions, producing music and being generally ‘creative’, another word that is difficult to define.

 

Can they be independently taught?

Of course, those who are most vociferous on the subject of 21st C skills are often those who tend to ‘write’ most about them but are the least skilled in them. Education, whether through lectures in Universities or one teacher to 30 plus kids in a classroom, is not the way to teach any of these skills, even if they did exists. Of course, education continued to scrap vocational learning, starve it of funding and push for even more abstract schooling and higher education. So called 21st C skills were fine for others but not them.

 

Isn’t all this talk of 21st C skills just a rather old, top-down, command and control idea – that we know what’s best for others? Isn’t it just the old master-pupil model dressed up in new clothes? Do the pupils know a tad more about digital skills than the masters?

 

It is an illusion that these skills were ever, or even can be, taught at school. Teachers have enough on their plate without being given this burden. I’ve seen no evidence that teachers have the disposition, or training, to teach these skills. In fact, in universities, I’d argue that smart, highly analytic, research-driven academics tend, in my experience, often to have low skills in these areas. Formal educational environments are not the answer. Pushing rounded, sophisticated, informal skills into a square, subject-defined environment is not the answer. It is our schools and universities, not young people, who need to be dragged into the 21st century. The change will comes through mass adoption and practice, not formal education. 

 

Conclusion

There’s a brazen conceit here, that educators know, with certainty, that these are the chosen skills for the next 100 years. Are we simply fetishising the skills of the current management class? Was there a sudden break between these skills in the last century compared to this century? No. What’s changed is the need to understand the wider range of future possibilities and stop relying on human exceptionalism.

 

Bibliography

Mirjam Neelen & Paul A. Kirschner  ‘21ST CENTURY SKILLS DON’T EXIST. SO WHY DO WE NEED THEM?’ (2016). https://3starlearningexperiences.wordpress.com/2016/11/01/21st-century-skills-dont-exist-so-why-do-we-need-them/

Rotherham, A.J., & Willingham, D.T., (2010). “21st-Century” skills. Not new, but a worthy challenge. American Educator, 17-20. https://www.aft.org/sites/default/files/periodicals/RotherhamWillingham.pdf

Arum, R. and Roksa, J., (2011). Academically adrift: Limited learning on college campuses. University of Chicago Press. 

Thursday, March 05, 2015

Forget 21st Century skills - revive 18th Century skills

A mantra (that has now turned into an empty trope) among educators who need a serious sounding phrase to rattle around in conferences and reports is ‘21st Century Skills’. I hear it often, almost always in some overlong, text-heavy Powerpoint presentation at an educational conference, accompanied by a cocktail of 'C' words  - collaboration, communication, creativity, critical skills. Can the real world really be that alliterative?
But does this idee fixe bear scrutiny? In a nice piece of work by Stepahnie Otttenheijm, she asked some youngsters (radical eh?) what 21st C skills they thought they’d need. Not one of the usual suspects came up. They were less vague, much bolder and far more realistic. Rather than the usual 'C' suspects and abstract nouns, they wanted to know how to handle and maintain a strong digital identity, be nice, recognise what’s learnt outside school, learn how to search, use Facebook privacy settings and so on - exceedingly practical these youngsters. My suspicion is that they know far more about this than we adults. It is schools, colleges and Universities that need to be dragged into the 21st century, not their users.
This 21st C agenda is actually quite dangerous. It can harm learners, especially the disadvantaged by giving them the illusion of progress. Knowledge and skills are not separable like oil and water, they are deeply entwined with most critical think and problem solving requiring a depth off knowledge. Willingham point's to the disastrous adoption of 'New Math', a let straight into problem solving which abandoned necessary, prior knowledge. 21st C skills promise short-cuts, short-term gains but at a heavy cost - long-term progress.

18th century skills
I'm all for abandoning this ‘21st century’ label - we're 15% into it already and education has become less interested in these skills, more academic, more test-driven, PISA obsessed and has failed to use the technology that we all use, even during the dull lectures we're still fed. Forget futurists, I want some educational archaeologists that revive 18th century enlightenment values.
Samuel Johnson said, "Lectures were once useful; but now, when all can read, and books are so numerous, lectures are unnecessary. If your attention fails, and you miss a part of a lecture, it is lost; you cannot go back as you do upon a book". The figures who led the charge against the religious basis of schooling and universities in the enlightenment were people like Johnson, who existed outside of the system, enjoyed unorthodox opinion and encouraged real critical thinking. As he said, "Curiosity is one of the most permanent and certain characteristics of a vigorous intellect".
What drove him and other enlightenment figures, like Mary Wollstonecraft and Rousseau, was a more sympathetic view of the learner but above all the basic idea of self-improvement and education as a progressive force.
David Hume, my favourite enlightenment figure, and the greatest ever English speaking philosopher, who was rejected by Edinburgh University for being an 'unbeliever', would be shocked to find that find religious studies, and not philosophy, is still taught in schools. "Scholastic learning and polemical divinity retarded the growth of all true knowledge" he claimed.
Why teach the love of a set of incompatible systems of certainty, rather than the love of critical thought, a sceptical disposition and autonomous thinking. On learning he was incredibly progressive, observing that "it is the content, not the person who matters... as you know there is nothing to be learnt from a Professor, which is not to be met with in books, and there is nothing to be required in order to reap all possible advantages from them, but an order and choice in reading them...I see no reason why we should either go to a University, more than to any other place, or ever trouble ourselves about the learning or capacity of the professor."
I'd prefer young people to have the skills that keep them sceptical, critical and independent. Genuine inquiry needs that enlightenment spirit of curiosity, good analytic skills and abandonment of dogmatic positions. To be honest, I suspect they have this in abundance. Like their enlightenment forefathers they don't want to lock up knowledge in institutions but share, discuss, communicate, even hang out in coffee shops.
Collaboration and sharing
Young people communicate and collaborate every few minutes – it’s an obsession. They text, message, chat, post, comment, snapchat, whatsapp, use Instagram, Facebook and tools you're likely never to have heard of. Note the absence of email and Twitter. Then there’s Spotify, Soundcloud, Flickr, Vine, Vimeo, YouTube and Bitorrent to share, tag, upload and download experiences, comments, photographs, video and media. They also collaborate closely in teams, often international, when playing computer games. Never have the young shared so much, so often in so many different ways. 
Then along comes someone who wants to teach them a 21st C skill, usually in a classroom, where all of this is banned. I’m hugely amused at this conceit, that we adults, especially in education, think we always have the skills we want to teach. There is no area of human endeavour that is less collaborative than education. Teaching and lecturing are largely lone-wolf activities in classrooms. Schools, colleges and Universities share little. Educational professionals are deeply suspicious of anything produced outside of their classroom or their institution. The culture of NIH (Not Invented Here) is endemic. Many educators far from being consistently collaborative, have a sneering attitude towards online collaboration.
Communication
Again, we live in the age of abundant communication. There’s been a renaissance in communication and writing among young people, who have become masters at smart, concise dialogue. The mobile has taken communication to new levels of use and sophistication. They know what channel to use, whether it’s archived (txts & Facebook) or not (snapchat), synchronous (realtime voice) or asynchronous (access when you want). They can also handle multiple, open channels at the same time.
What do we educators have to offer on this front? Whiteboards? Some groupwork round a table with felt-tip pens? Not one single teacher in the schools my sons attended has an email address available for parents. I’ve attended innumerable educational conferences where only a handful of the participants used Twitter.
Problem solving
Problem solving is a complex skill and there are serious techniques that you can learn to problem solve, such as breakdown, root-cause analysis, supplemented by good documentation, issues' lists, request registers and so on. If you've been through serious project management training or lived for a while in a heavyweight IT environment, where serious coding takes place, you'll meet people who are skilled at this. 
I’m not at all convinced that many subject-focused teachers and lecturers know much about these generic techniques. Problem solving for a maths teacher may be factoring equations of finding a proof but they’re the last people I’d call on to solve anything else in life. Do teachers actually know what generic problem solving is or is it seen as some skill that is acquired through osmosis when a group of kids get together in a project to make, for example, a movie?
Creativity
Beware of big, abstract nouns. This one has become a cipher for almost everything and, I fear, nothing. I have no problem with art, drama and other departments talking about creativity but why does creativity have to be injected into all subjects and education. When it comes to creativity, my own view is that the music, drama and other creative skills my own offspring have gained, have mostly been acquired outside of school. You can listen to as many Sir Ken Robinson talks as you wish, it's still a vague concept backed up with little more than his easy-going, jokey rhetoric.
Critical thinking
I have some sympathy with this one, as critical thinking is often well taught in good schools and universities, but it needs high quality teaching and the whole curriculum and system of assessment needs to adjust to this need. However, as Arun has shown, there is evidence that in our Universities, this is not happening. Arun (2011), in a study that tracked a nationally representative sample of more than 2,000 students, who entered 24 four-year colleges, showed that Universities were failing badly on the three skills they studied; critical thinking, complex reasoning and communications. This research, along with similar evidence, is laid out in their book Academically Adrift.
Digital literacy
Across the world young people have collaborated on Blogs, Twitter, Facebook and YouTube to bring down entire regimes and force political change. Not one of them has been on a digital literacy course. And, in any case, who are these older teachers who know enough about digital literacy to teach these young people? And how do they teach it – through collaborative, communication on media using social media – NO. By and large, in educational institutions, this stuff is shunned, restricted, even banned. We learn digital literacy by doing, largely outside of academe.
Conclusion
Beneath all this talk of 21st C skills, is not a view of autonomy and independent skills and thinking. Isn’t it just a rather old, top-down, command and control idea – that we know what’s best for them? Isn’t it just the old master-pupil model dressed up in new clothes? In this case, I suspect the pupils may know a tad more than the masters.
There’s also a brazen conceit here, that educators know, with certainty, that these are the chosen skills for the next 100 years. Are we simply fetishising the skills of the current management class? Was there a sudden break between these skills in the last century compared to this century? No. What’s changed is the need to understand the wider range of possible communication channels. This comes through mass adoption and practice, not formal education.

It is an illusion that these skills were ever, or even can be, taught at school. Teachers have enough on their plate without being given this burden. I’ve seen no evidence that teachers have the disposition, or training, to teach these skills. In fact, in universities, I’d argue that smart, highly analytic, research-driven academics tend, in my experience, often to have low skills in these areas. Formal educational environments are not the answer. Pushing rounded, sophisticated, informal skills into a square, subject-defined environment is not the answer. It’s our schools and universities, not young people, who need to be dragged into the 21st century.

Monday, March 23, 2020

Willingham – Cognitive science in teaching… critic of learning styles and 21st C skills…

Daniel Willingham, Professor of Psychology at the University of Virginia, has a background in research on learning and memory which he has masterfully turned into concrete advice for teachers in schools. He is an advocate for turning research in cognitive science into practice in education, both in teaching and the promotion of optimal study strategies for learners.

Knowledge matters
Memory matters as we have instant recall from long-term memory which helps us make instinctive decisions. This is why Willingham derides those who demote knowledge at the expense of teaching and learning strategies that focus largely on exploratory or discovery learning. 

Nine cognitive principles 

In Why Don't Students Like School? Willingham has nine cognitive principles about learners, which if taken on board by teachers, will improve teacher performance. He thinks that thinking does not come naturally to learners and that one must be sensitive to a number if findings in cognitive science to be an optimal teacher and learner. Memory and cognition really do matter and to ignore what we know about these findings in cognitive science is, for Willingham, to work blind or worse to adopt fads live learning styles and the 21st century skills agenda. These are his nine cognitive principles:
1 Curious
People are naturally curious, but they are not naturally good thinkers.
2 Knowledge
Factual knowledge must precede skill.
3 Memory
Memory is the residue of thought.
4 Understanding
We understand new things in the context of things we already know and most of what we know is concrete.
5 Proficiency
It is virtually impossible to become proficient at a mental task without extended practice.
6 Cognition
Cognition early in training is fundamentally different from cognition late in training.
7 Differences
Children are more alike than different in terms of how they think and learn.
8 Intelligence
Children do differ in intelligence, but intelligence can be changed through sustained hard work.
9 Teaching
Teaching, like any complex cognitive skill, must be practice to be improved.

Learning styles

A critic of learning styles, he thinks that teachers mistake the idea that learners are different for other differences, especially ‘ability’. His belief that knowledge precedes skills has led to his critique of the teaching of 21st century skills. Like almost all cognitive psychologists, he thinks the evidence is clear that ‘learning styles’ do not exist. He thinks that learning styles as a theory of how people learn, a theory of learning, is quite simply false.

21st century skills

Willingham thinks that the 21st century skills agenda is not only flawed but dangerous, in that it harms the poorest students and students of colour hardest. The flaw, he thinks, is in thinking that knowledge and skills are separate entities, when they are entwined. To think critically or creatively or to problem solve is to use knowledge central to the domain. To be creative or critical in science or coding, you need to know science and how to code. The danger is in introducing complex 21st century skills too early (he quotes ‘New Maths of the 60s as an example). He is sceptical about teaching self-direction, collaboration, creativity, and innovation. Are they teachable or just an excuse to bring back exploratory learner-centric models? There is little evidence that they can be taught and, in practice, teachers rarely employ this approach in practice. So, without clear proof that they can be taught, better assessment the focus on “21st-century skills” will be shallow. This mean we “will sacrifice long-term gains for the appearance of short-term progress”.

Influence

Willingham is seen as part of the backlash against progressive methods, that many see as not only having gone too far but actually harmful to poor students.

Bibliography

Willingham, D.T., 2009. Why don't students like school?: A cognitive scientist answers questions about how the mind works and what it means for the classroom. John Wiley & Sons.
Willingham, D.T., 2007. Critical thinking: Why it is so hard to teach?. American federation of teachers summer 2007, p. 8-19.
Rotherham, A.J. and Willingham, D.T., 2010. 21st-Century” skills. American Educator, 17(1), pp.17-20.
Willingham, D.T., Hughes, E.M. and Dobolyi, D.G., 2015. The scientific status of learning styles theories. Teaching of Psychology, 42(3), pp.266-271.

Saturday, March 16, 2019

Ai starts to crack the critical thinking... astonishing experiment...

Just eighteen years after 2001 (older readers will know the significance of that date), the AI-debater on the left, a 6 foot high black stele, with a woman’s voice, used arguments, objections, rebuttals, even jokes, to tussle with her opponent. She lost but, in a way, she also won, as this points towards an interesting breed of critical thinking software.  This line of AI has significance in the learning world.
How does it work?
First, she creates an opening speech by searching through millions of opening gambits, removes extraneous text and looks for the highest probability claims and arguments, based on solid evidence, she then arranges these arguments thematically to give a four minute speech.  In critical conversation,  she then listens to your response and responds, debating the point step by step. This where it gets clever as it she has to cope with logical dilemmas and structured debate and argument, drawing on a huge corpus of knowledge, way beyond what any human could read and remember.
Debate
In learning, working through a topic through dialogue, debate and discussion is often useful. Putting your ideas to the test, in an assignment or research task or when writing an article for publication and so on, would be a useful skill for my Alexa to be able to deliver. It raises the game, as it pushes AI generated responses beyond knowledge into reasoned argument and checks on evidence from trusted sources. But a debate is not the great win here. There are other more interesting and scalable uses.
Critical thinking
Much of the talk about 21st century skills is rather cliched, with little in the way of evidence-based debate. The research suggests that these skills, far from being separate 'skills' are largely domain specific. You don't get far in being a creative, critical and problem solving thinker in, say Data Science, if you don't know a lot about...  well... Data science. What's interesting about this experiment is the degree to which general debating skills,, let's call it stating and defending or attacking a proposition, shows how one can untangle, say critical thinking, into its components, as it has to be captured and delivered as software.
There are some key lessons here, as the logo of debate is actually the logic we know from Aristotle onwards, syllogistic and complex, often beyond the capability of the human brain. On the other hand the heuristics we humans use are a real challenge for AI. But AI is rising to this challenge with all sorts of techniques, many species of supervised and unsupervised AI that learns through machine learning, fuzzy logic to cope (largely with the impreciseness of language and human expression) and a battery of statistical theory and probability theory to determine certainty.
This, along with GTP-2 (I've written about this here), which creates content, along with techniques embedded in Google Duplex around complex conversational rules, are moving learning AI into new territory, with real dialogue based on structured creation of content, voice and the flow of conversations and debate. Why is this important?
1. Teaching
When it reaches a certain standard, we can see how it starts to behave like a teacher, to engage with a learner in dialogue and interpret the strengths of arguments, debate with the student, even teach and assess critical thinking and problem solving. In a sense it may transform normal teaching, in being able to deliver personalised learning at this level, on scale. The skills of a good teacher or lecturer are to introduce a subject, engage learners, support learners, assess learners. Even if it does not perform the job of an experienced teacher, one could see how it could support teachers.
2. Communication skills
There is also the ability to raise one’s game by using it as a foil to improve one’s communication skills, as a learner, teacher, presenter, interviewer, coach, therapist or sales person. Being able to persuade it that you are right, based on evidence, is something we could all benefit from. It strikes me that it could in time, also identify and help correct various human biases, especially confirmation bias but many others. Daniel Kahneman, in his Thinking Fast and Slow makes an excellent point at the very end of the book when he says that these biases are basically 'uneducable'. In other words, they are there, and rather than trying to change them, which is near impossible, we must tame them.
3. Expert
With access to over 300 million articles it has digested more than any human can read and remember in a lifetime. But this is just for reference. The degree to which it can use this as evidence for argument and advice is interesting. The experiment seems to support the idea that domain knowledge really does matter in critical thinking, something largely ignored in the superficial debate at conferences on 21st century skills. This may untangle this complex area by showing us how trues expertise is developed and executed.
4. Practice
The advantages the machine has over humans is the consistent access and use of very large knowledge bases. One can foresee a system that is an expert in a multitude of subjects and able to deliver scalable and sophisticated practice in not only knowledge but higher order skills across a range of subjects. The development of expertise takes time application and practice. This offers the opportunity to accelerate expertise. Of course, it also suggests that expertise may be replaces may machines. Read that sentence again, as it has huge consequences.
5. Assessment
If successful, such software could be a sophisticated way to assess learner’s work, whether written work, essays or oral, as it puts their arguments to the test. This is the equivalent to a VIVA or oral exam. With more structured questions, one could see how more sophisticated and objective assessment, free from essay mills and cheating, could be delivered.
6. Decision making
One could also see a use in decision-making, where evidence-based arguments would be at least worth exploring, while humans still make the decisions. I’d love, as a manager, to make a decision based on what has been found to work, rather than guessing or relying on faddish decision making.
Conclusion
This will, eventually, be invaluable for a teaching assistant that never gets tired, inattentive, demotivated, crabby and delivers quality learning experiences, not just answering questions. It may also help eliminate human bias in educational processes, making them more meritocratic. Above all it holds the promise of high level teaching that is scalable and cheap. At the very least it may lift often crass debate around 21st century skills beyond their cliched presentation as lists in bad PowerPoint presentations at conferences.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Leadbetter's 21 Ideas for 21st Century Learning

Charles Leadbetter tries hard to be a web guru and while adored by the London media luvvies, he is completely ignored by everyone else. I once attended, as a guest, a Channel 4 board dinner, and was treated like a pariah when I suggested that Charlie was a fake. He may have the thick-rimmed glasses, open shirt, cardigan and fashionably shaved head, but his ideas are second hand and he jumps on bandwagons well after the circus has left town.

WE-THINK - I think not
WE-THINK is his latest offering and it is no better than his previous efforts. He desperately tries to get this phrase into comon parlance through repetition in this rather dull book, but fails.

However, in his defence I did come across a rather interesting paper, amazingly, commissioned by the Innovation Unit. This unit is famous for NEVER answering emails or engaging with anyone in the real world. You could only ever get near them by attending boring government meetings. They were about as uninnovative (is that a real word), and closed to ideas, as you can get.

Then again, this is a very readable document, and although hopelessly optimistic, it is brimming with ideas. I loved this quote, “It is very difficult to get teachers away from the idea that learning can only happen when they are in charge of everything. They have to realise that learning sometimes happens precisely because they are not in charge of everything but the pupils are.” And here are the 21 ideas:

21 Ideas for 21st Century Learning

1. Individual Budgets and Self Directed Support Plans for Families at Risk

2. Emotional Resilience Programme

3. The Learning Concierge Service

4. Break up Large Schools

5. The Peer Learner Programme

6. The Personal Challenge

7.. Personal Learning Plans and Portfolios

8. A Right to Intensive Mentoring

9. Personal Budgets for Young People in Danger of Becoming NEET

10. Investors in Learning

11. Schools as Productive Enterprises

12. Scrap the Six Week Summer Holiday

13. The School of Everything for Schools

14. Community-Based Teacher

15. Third Spaces

16. Whole School Projects for the Community

17. Local Education Compacts

18. Participatory Budgeting

19. Leadership Teams not Headteachers

20. Wider Measures of Progress and Outcomes

21. A National Curriculum for Capabilities