Friday, October 02, 2020

Fun, humour... it's place in learning...

Should all learning be fun? No one is against a bit of fun on principle but as an imperative for learning, it is an odd goal. It’s a word that rarely figures in learning theory or the psychology of learning, yet some swear by it motivational effect in games and gamification of learning through play.

One purveyor of mirth, during a keynote at a major global conference I attended, started with his usual appeal to the audience… 

Let me give you another word for fun - HA HA (that’s two words, but let’s not quibble)…. turn to your neighbour and say that without one letter”. 

Some, like my neighbour, were genuinely puzzled ‘HAH?’ he said. 

I think it’s ‘AHA’, says I.

Oh dear. This guy wanted all learning to be like Broadway. He then showed a police training video with six police officers dancing in a six-ball pool formation singing a song. Everything has to be fun? Eh… maybe not.

Icebreakers that go down like the Titanic

In practice, fun is often used to kick-start training sessions through ice-breakers. Although even here the dangers are evident. Whipping out a ukulele and singing The Jungle Book, stopping to ask for the next word is simply patronising (true story). Ice-breakers like this go down as well as the Titanic. Many dislike the touchy-feely stuff that passes for introductory fun and they can make educators and trainers seem frivolous, lightweight, even ridiculous. There’s no harm in setting the tone, and getting attention, as good trainers and facilitators do but making people squirm is not exactly the point.

Worst piece of online learning EVER?


Turning to fun in online learning, the worst example of online learning I've ever seen, was ridiculed by PewDiePie, a legend among his 100+ million YouTube followers. He lives in my home town, Brighton, and has built his reputation on videos that praise, review games. Unusually, this piece of US gamified, online learning on Cybersecurity was his target and he eviscerates it. It is a hilarious example of endless attempts at ‘fun’; condescending scenarios, special effects, awful multiple-choice questions, interspersed with screens packed with text, even a game within a game. 

It both looks and feels awful. Not sure where the art direction came from but it’s all over the place. All wacky cartoon-style learning. It tries SO hard to be engaging with 3D animated characters but they are straight out of the clichéd, clip-art, playbook. Then the animated effects that slide, whoosh and pop up like a disjointed, surreal dream. We need to sit our teams of content designers down, and scream out the simple principle – LESS IS MORE. We have decades of research showing that all of this ‘noise’ inhibits, not enhances, learning. 

It is clearly a game designed by someone who has no actual knowledge computer games, not uncommon in online learning design. So determined are they to gamify everything, they completely kill off the learning. You get a lot of this in online learning, badly executed, Pavlovian nonsense. Like one of those ‘so bad it’s good’ cult movies. It is funny but for all the wrong reasons.

How can I sum this up. It should be compulsory to show this example in ALL instructional design courses, as an example of how NOT to design learning experiences. It is so surreal that it could pass for a deliberate takedown of online learning. When online learning has come to this, you know it is time for a rethink. Enough already with the overblown cartoons, graphics and grotesque gamification. Stop. Slow down. Keep it simple. This is what used to be called edutainment but it is neither edu nor tainment, it is the ugly cul-de-sac of an industry that has abandoned learning for cheap media production. It shows the danger in over-egging ‘experiences’ forgetting that they must be ‘learning experiences’.

Humour

Humour has a useful role in life and also in learning, But again, ike the word ‘fun’ let’s not get carried away. Humour is best used sparingly, too lift things or play the role it plays in normal life. The harder, sharper term ‘humour’ is in many ways more interesting than ‘fun’. Humour plays an important role in social behaviour, cementing relationships, revealing attitudes and generally has a cohesive social effect. It can be used that way in learning. In learning it can introduce and disarm unease around sensitive concepts, grab and gain attention, lift learners when they are flagging. Jokes use incongruities, they raise arousal and depend on the fall, they provide relief. 

Yet grand theories of humour, from Plato to Freud have largely been abandoned in favour of a more detailed analysis in cognitive psychology, where it is seen as many different things in different contexts. And there’s the rub, you must be very careful with humour as its nature, how it manifests itself and value, varies from culture to culture. It is easy to come across as crass or insensitive. Then again, when the moment is right, it can have a place.

I’m a fan of stand-up comedy and attend the Edinburgh Festival every year and watch a ton a lot of comedy. But, honestly, I can barely remember a couple of jokes from the hundreds of hours I’ve ‘experienced’ at live comedy. It was fun but they were not ‘learning’ experiences. There’s a very big difference. A touch of humour certainly helps raise attention but learning is not stand-up comedy. In fact, we famously forget most jokes, as they don’t fit into existing knowledge schemas. Fun can be the occasional cherry on the cake but never the whole cake.

There is a real danger in pandering to this kindergarten view of learning, where fun has to be injected into learning experiences. Learning is not a circus and teachers are not clowns.

Games and gamification

The massive success of online games led many to suggest that games and gamification, could be used to turbo-charge online learning. Take a little magic dust from gaming, sprinkle generously and we’ll all find it more fun, be more motivated and learn to love learning. But there’s pros and cons here, as it can both help and hinder learning. If gamification is simply scoring, bonuses and badges, the 21st century version of Pavlov's dogs, that would be a disappointment. So much gamified learning looks like a bad fruit machine. The simple stimuli, scores and rewards may keep learners going forward but it can distract from the learning, distract in the sense of encouraging the winning of the game rather than achieving learning objectives, shallow forms of engagement and the disappointment of playing astounding games at home and getting micky-mouse games in learning. The dangers is that of skating across the surface of content. It may will demand more cognitive effort, as the rules of the game and its mechanics will have to be understood and acted upon, for not much gain. The very word is off-putting for many. Don’t assume that because you like and play games that others have the same view. The danger is in taking learning back to the behaviourist era, with simple, Pavlovian, conditioned responses, or S-O-R theory. 

On the other hand, many proven, evidence-based pieces of learning theory seem to be congruent with games techniques, such as chunking, levels of performance, constructive failure, practice, doing and performance. It can be personalized when adaptive and provides specific advantages when repeated practice is necessary. Above all it has motivational qualities, although we need to be careful here as phenomena like leaderboards can have short-lived benefits.

I like the light touch gamification in Duolingo - sprints, adaptive and spaced practice. When gamification is congruent with good principles in learning theory, it has the power to increase the effectiveness of the learning.  I’m fond of the chunking, repeats and mastery but less keen on superficial scores, bonuses and badges. That’s not to say they don’t have a place but they often seem like a superfluous layer of complexity.

Learning

It is important that learners are motivated, attentive, listening, making the effort to understand and reflect, doing things, not just reacting. Audience reaction is arousal, not attention, what entertainment does. Audience focus, attention and participation is what learners do. Fun can certainly be used to raise attention, at the start of a learning experience. A list of dull learning objectives at the start of every course or module is no one’s idea of fun. Learning is about focused attention.

We should not mistake fun for other concepts, like attention, being engrossed, gripped or immersed in a task, in fact flow or being in the zone requires an absence of this type opf over-stimulation and arousal. I have read literally thousands of books in my life and rarely chortled while reading them. Athletes learn intensely in their sports and barely register a titter. Learning requires attention, focus and effort, not a good giggle. Only those who think that teaching is actually about performance or those whose only form of evaluation is ‘Happy sheets’, adhere to the nonsense that learning should be ALL fun. Others make non sequiturs, claiming that those who disagree that ALL learning should be fun, think that all learning should be dull and boring. No. Just because I don’t think that all clothes should be white, doesn’t mean I believe they should all be black. 

It is this obsession that led to the excesses of gamification, with its battery of Pavlovian techniques, which mostly distract from the effort needed to learn and retain. It is what’s led to a lot of online learning being click-through cartoons, speech bubbles, largely the presentation of text, graphics and video, with little in the way of effortful learning, apart from multiple-choice options. 

It is not that some fun and the affective side of learning don't matter, just that it is pointless motivating people to embark on learning experiences if they don't actually learn. This is not a false dichotomy, between fun and learning, it is the recognition that there are optimal learning strategies. A touch of humour certainly helps raise attention but learning is not comedy. In fact, we famously forget most jokes, as they don’t fit into existing knowledge schemas. Fun can be the occasional cherry on the cake but never the whole cake.

Which is why open input, effortful learning tools like WildFire result in much higher levels of retention. When designers focus relentlessly on fun they more often than not, destroy learning. There is perhaps no greater sin in online learning than presenting adults with hundreds of screens of cartoons, speech bubbles and endless clicking, in the name of ‘fun’.

'Fun', funnily enough, can be a rather sad word – like the children’s clown walking to the gate after a kid’s party, even tragic. It has the whiff of the kindergarden and diminishes and demeans learning. There’s an emptiness at the heart of the learning game. A refusal to accept that we know a lot about learning, that research matters. The purveyors of fun, and those who think it’s a performance art, in the end tend to serve up the sort of nonsense that creates superficial, click-through, online learning. 

In truth, learning is about focus, attention, reflection (often serious introspection), retrieval, practice, application and transfer. Learning is not a circus and teachers are not clowns.

37 comments:

weighbridge manufacturers said...

This blog is truly amazing we are the leading Weighbridge manufacturers

Anu said...

Very well written
Best Data Science Training In Hyderabad

Brian Wendt said...

awesome post. Such a nice blog i really like what you write in these blog i also have some relevent information about

Higher Education School

Tim James said...

Hi guys I'm TIM , I was disorganized because i had a very small penis, about 2.0 inches soft and 4 inches hard not nice enough to satisfy my woman, I have been in so many relationship, but cut off because of my situation, i have used so many product which doctors prescribe for me, but none could offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments on the internet about this herbal doctor called Dr Aziba and decided to contact him on WhatsApp with his mobile no (+2348100368288) I saw on the internet, I decided to give his herbal product a try. he gave me some comforting words with his herbal product for Penis Enlargement, Within A week of use I began to feel the enlargement of my penis, " and now it just 3 weeks of using his products my penis is about 9 inches longer, and I had to settle out with my Ex girlfriend, I was surprised when she said that she is satisfied with my sex and i have got a large penis. Am so happy, thanks to Dr Aziba I also learn that Dr Aziba also help with Breast Enlargement Hips and Bums Enlargement, Low Sperm Count, If you are in any situation with a little Penis, weak ejaculation, small breast_ hips_ bums do get to Dr Aziba contact him now on his mobile no, or add him up on WhatsApp (+2348100368288) Email ( Priestazibasolutioncenter@gmail.com )

Anonymous said...

This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic.
It contains true information about student accommodation in abroad.
For the best accommodation properties just visit this site.
student accommodation near CASS Business School

Unknown said...

Is Taking Digital Marketing As A Career Worth It?
Digital Marketing.

umair said...

Like!! The blog is quite often and I genuinely thank you for your information about benefits of automation. The article has truly peaked my interest.

dominguezmarta said...

Most binary options companies out there are fraudulent. They are all scams. I have been a victim of their activities. I invested about $480,000 and when i wanted to withdraw after some months, I was unable to reach their contact numbers or emails with which we stayed in touch. I assumed they were having some maintenance routing check, as that had happened in the past. After some weeks, I was contacted again by them and was asked to invest which i refused and told them i wanted to withdraw my money. After this, i didn’t hear from them again. At this point, I started to feel like i had been duped. I was lost and shattered as i had lost most of my savings. I was depressed for about 3 months. I was too ashamed to tell anyone about it, not even my children. I finally summoned the courage to tell my friend who came to visit me in the UK from New Zealand. He told me about a man who specializes on helping get money back called (Troy Hermes) that he's one of the top heads in one of the CIA departments.
I contacted through the email address I was given after much research about him. and surprisingly I was guided to recovering 93% of my money back. It was a great feeling to get my money back, as i had given up all hope. You can also contact him through the mail address.
(troyhermes8@gmail.com)
Note: I had to share this information because I had the feeling of helping scam victims as I was.
If you see this and you are not actually a victim kindly copy and share for others.
Someone other there needs to be saved.
Thanks and be safe.

5Star Processing said...

If you run a business in the adult payment processing industry, you have probably encountered that getting a payment gateway and a merchant account for adult payment processing is not so easy.

Williams Pater said...

Hello everyone i Am williams pater and i am from USA i am here to give my testimony about an herbal doctor called Dr,olu I was heartbroken because i had very small penis,not nice to satisfy a woman, i have been in so many relationship, but cut off because of my situation, i have used so many product which doctors prescribe for me, but could not offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments on the internet about this specialist called Dr,OLU and decided to email him on his email i saw on the internet,(drolusolutionhome@gmail.com ) so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal product for Penis Enlargement, Within three weeks of me use it, i began to feel the enlargement, " and now it just 4 weeks of using his products my penis is about 8 inches longer, and i had to settle thing out with my ex girlfriend , i was surprised when she said that she is satisfied with my performance in bed and i now have a large penis.thanks to DR OLU for is herbal product. you can also reach him with emsil  drolusolutionhome@gmail.com though is..number WHATASPP him today on this number [ +2348140654426 ]

Jhon Michael said...

Red Hat Certified Engineer is a professional who has expertise in handling the Red Hat Enterprise Linux System. The Certified Engineer takes care of various tasks such as setting kernel runtime parameters, handling various types of system logging and providing certain kinds of network operability. The professionals must have the ability to install networking services and security on servers running Red Hat Enterprise Linux.

Red Hat Certified Engineer

UplayOnline said...




GD Casino
Premium Casino

Aol Mail Login said...

Logging in the configuration panel of your router is easy by entering 192.168.1.1
in your browser of choice address bar. After successful login as admin or administrative user at your router you are given the possibility to set various configuration options among which: Resetting the Admin Password, Quality of Service, DNS servers, Proxy setup, LAN and WAN configuration, network management, security options, Wi-Fi settings, PPPOE, WPS and DHCP automatic IP assignments.
Regards: 123.hp.com/setup

khushi said...

Thanks for sharing the blog, seems to be interesting and informative too.
Latest Insurance Policy In India

Lisa King said...

Remember when we were kids and kindergarten was a time to tie your shoes and learn. Well, times have changed and it seems that all we hear about today is the common basic standard and politicians are being urged to "prepare for college" for students. I think now the online treasure and pleasure resources are the online helping services such as https://www.essayking.co.uk/do-my-essay/.

Nicki Minaz said...

Another great learning experience. The author has an unique way that makes me feel like i am getting advice from an old friend who genuinely cares. I love how passionate and motivating he is. Love your energy and accessible wisdom in explaining Windows Versions. You have done a great job.

Anonymous said...

Welcome to the top 10 online brokers. Ever since the time we started the section, we have focused on the decent analysis of the several discount stock brokers to present you the best discount broker in India.

UplayOnline said...




Casino Deluxe

GD Casino

360digitmgdelhi said...

I'm cheerful I found this blog! Every now and then, understudies need to psychologically the keys of beneficial artistic articles forming. Your information about this great post can turn into a reason for such individuals.
data science course in delhi

Viki Natrin said...

You have 3 million views on this video, but 108 million of subscribers. Have you bought subscribers from this site https://soclikes.com/buy-youtube-subscribers? Or I made a mistake?

Shivani said...

Thank you for sharing a knowledge, and looking forward for more information like this.
Top Trading Company In India

Best Insurance Policy said...

Very help full content and such amazing information for me. Get complete guide on insurance policies in India 2021...Visit our blog!!!!Best insurance policy
Best bike insurance company in India
Health insurance companies
Best car insurance company in India

fuel digital vignesh said...

This is very good post I have read and I must appreciate you to have written this for us.Its really informative.
Best Digital Marketing Agency in Chennai
website design in chennai

Wales Publications said...

Wales publications are committed to helping the authors through our predefined and well-managed services. We are offering many Research Papers Services
for authors to comply with the author's guidelines defined by the journals and the guideline for submitting the research in our journals.

Wales Publications said...

The fast submission process includes rapid Publication Research in UK that includes unique rapid process, inhouse peer review and 100% acceptance guarantee.

Unknown said...

Hello everyone , here’s your opportunity for you to achieve your dreams of being a multi million dollar rich through trading , I once loss all I got through trading but was fortunate to come across a woman with great virtue and selfless heart (Mary ) i was introduce to her masterclass strategy while searching online which has revived me of all my losses and made me gain more and more . With her unique strategy you are entitled to daily signals and instant withdraw ,be rest assured of getting a refund of all your loss investment with any platform that has denied you in one way or the other in getting your money . Mr Payton masterclass strategy is simply the best for beginners and those that are finding it difficult to succeed through trading he’ll help you with just a simple step . Email her ( paytondyian699@Gmail.com) .Remember this is absolutely free!!!

Michael Patriciaa said...

Hello everyone i know there is someone somewhere reading this, My name is Nancy Perez from Leicester city, England, I want to share a great work of a spell caster called Dr Iyaya, my husband and i had a fight which led to our divorce but when he left me a part of me left with him and i was to sad and cried all day and night i was searching something online when i saw people testifying about his great work and i just decided to give him a try i did everything he told me to do and he assured me that after 24 hours my husband will come back to me,the next morning to my greatest surprised a car stopped outside my house and it was my husband i'm so happy he can also help you email him at doctoriyaya@gmail.com or WhatsApp him at +2347032756397
?? visit his website you may found your solution there www.https://dr-iyaya-herbal-remedy.webnode.com God bless you sir.

cacpvtltd said...

Thanks for this blog. It really provides awesome information to all readers. keep it up and keep posting these types of blogs on digital marketing services, it's really helpful.
retail audit companies

Best Demat Account said...

this is informative article !! Demat Account is the first thing that is needed to start share trading. Most beginners find it confusing as to what is Demat account and which is the best Demat Account. Demat Account is a digital storage account that stores shares in digital mode. Recall a bank account- what it does- it stores to cash in digital mode. best stock broker in india best discount broker in india

wisdom capital said...

thanks for shearing information !! Wisdom Capital is a genuine best discount broker in India. As per the research and analysis, we found the broker as trustworthy online discount broker. For your knowledge, it is also trending as the best stock broker in India|. Its distinctive idea is well admired by numerous traders across the country. They can positively enjoy the free trading offered in one of its brokerage plans.

BESTDISCOUNTSTOCKBROKER said...

Find out Best Discount Broker in India, compare top stock brokers in India offering discount brokerage, best trading platform & demat trading account in India.

cacpvtltd said...

Thanks for this blog. It really provides awesome information to all readers. keep it up and keep posting these types of blogs on digital marketing services, it's really helpful. business advisory firms in india

Brittany Seiber said...

To know more about Chief Dr Lucky you can visit his website (https://chiefdrluckyherbaltherapy.wordpress.com/)
 
 A friend that suffered from Herpes and was cure with the help of this great herbal doctor (Chief Lucky) so i decided to contact him for help in getting rid of my families genital herpes virus 1/2 which i did and all i was told to provide was just some useful information and some materials used in preparation of the natural cure and that i did and now i am the happiest person on earth because i am writing this testimony of mine with joy and happiness in my heart to the whole world to know that natural remedy is real because i am a living testimony of Chief Lucky traditional herbal cure and i want you all to contact Chief Lucky via his email: chiefdrlucky@gmail.com or WhatsApp him +2348132777335 am sure he will help you too.

Ronald Anthony said...

Thanks to Dr OSAGIE for helping me increase the size of my Penis. I have been married for 10 years and due to my small Penis I was unable to satisfy my wife and that made us childless and my wife planned to leave me I was really disappointed with myself and I was also having weak erection I thought all my hope was gone not until I saw a testimony on how the same Dr OSAGIE helped someone increase his Penis size. I was desperate to do anything to regain my sex life back and I contacted him and he promise to help me so he gave me a herbal mixture which i was using and after three days I began to experience changes. I am writing this testimony not only because he has helped me increase the size of my Penis, I can now satisfy my wife and my wife is three months pregnant. All thanks to Dr OSAGIE if you are having a weak erection problem or small Penis size contact him with his email:drosagiesolutionhome5 @ gmail. com or whats app him +2347035866588.  

Wisdompolicy said...

Great share!
If you are looking for Health Insurance plans. Get all types of life insurance plans like term, life, car, bike, life, health etc. Compare & Buy Online Best Family Health Insurance Plans In India . We are Providing a various insurance plans at a minimal premium. Compare Online Insurance Plan & Find with Benefits by top Health Insurance companies.

FTS Visa said...

Nice post, Thanks for sharing. Temporary Sponsored Visa Australia- FTS 

fuel digital vignesh said...

Thank you for post.It's truly informative will surely keep visiting the website.
I would highly appreciate if you guide me through this.
Ecommerce website designing company in Chennai
seo service in chennai
Best SEO analytics in Chennai
best google adwords campaign agencies in chennai
Pay per click (PPC) service in Chennai