While
Finland gets all the attention in education, lauded for its performance, few
look at the other end of the spectrum, the poor performers in Europe. So what’s
Europe’s poorest performing country? Guess what – the ever topical Greece.
Teacher-student ratios
Sadly,
Greece is a high cost, high staff but low attainment system. Greece has four
times more teachers per pupil than Finland, extremely low student-teacher
ratios in both primary and secondary but performs poorly in almost all areas. The
student-teacher staff ratio is an astonishing 7.66 in socio-economically
disadvantaged schools and 9.29 in advantaged schools, which are among the
smallest in PISA-participating countries. Only one country out of the sixty
one, has better (smaller) ratios. To put this in context, their student-teacher
ratios are twice as good as ours in the UK.
Teaching hours
The number
of hours primary teachers spend teaching in public institutions is
comparatively small in Greece, ranking 32nd smallest out of 33. Lower
secondary teachers teach the fewest hours of any country, ranking 33rd
out of 33. Upper secondary teachers are not much better at 32nd out
of 33. So, it’s lots of teachers, who teach less than in almost all other
countries.
Poor performance
When
students are asked whether they feel happy at school, Greece comes 56th out of
64. Nearly half of all students report skipping classes, which puts Greece a
disappointing 9th out of 64. So despite the low student-teacher
rations and high number of teachers, student attitudes are awful.
School culture
When it
comes to taking responsibility for the curriculum, course content and
assessment, Greece comes stone last 64th out of 64. It’s not much
better on the use of data to compare results and improve the system, where
they’re 63rd out of 64. In other words the system lacks flexibility
and oversight.
School guards
Lastly, and
this is an odd one, there’s the issue of school guards. This caused uproar in
the recent Grexit negotiations. The Greeks were criticized for overstaffing and
having ‘guards’ in schools, a subject that vexed outside observers from
countries where they do not exist. Interestingly, a significant number of these
‘guards’ had Masters degrees and PhDs. How do we know this? Because when the
guards were laid off a special exemption clause was inserted to preserve the
jobs of these over-qualified staff.
Conclusion
The data
suggests that the Greek school system has exemplary teacher-student ratios, but
the teachers teach less and the outcomes are dreadful. The school guards’ issue
simply shows that the system is somewhat out of control with regard to
staffing. Christos Tsolakis, an honorary
professor in the Education P Department of the Aristotle University of
Macedonia, saw poor education as the root cause of the Greek problem. “The economic problem is only the surface.
The real problem of Greece, however, is the educational lack as well as the
cultural crisis. Unfortunately, we Greeks have not yet clarified the meaning of
being educated. Ethical concepts such as understanding what is right and wrong,
respecting the laws, understanding the meaning of egalitarianism, rate,
measurement and democracy retreat in front of amorality have been long
forgotten”. Education would appear to show, in microcosm, some of the
problems the Greek state faces in implementing reform. Given the brouhaha over
school guards – a fight to the death to keep them all employed, the future
looks bleak.
No comments:
Post a Comment